# api

### 1. Introduction

The 9line Spaces system is a space booking platform created to support space management and booking functionalities. The system includes core functionalities such as User Management, Space Management, Appointment Booking, Rating System, Authentication/Authorization, RBAC (Role-Based Access Control), and Notification System.

### 2. Architecture

The system uses a clean architecture approach with Domain Driven Design (DDD). The front-end framework used is React/Next.js for web applications and React Native for mobile applications, highlighting its component-oriented architecture.

A REST API is utilized for data storage, consultation, and modification. The client application sends requests to URLs (endpoints) to access API services, and the API returns JSON objects.

### 3. Functionalities

| Functionalities         | Expected Behavior                                                                                                                                                                                                      | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                            | Acceptance Criteria                                                     |
| ----------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **User Registration**   | Upon entering name, email, password, and role, a registration will be performed on the platform, and the user should be redirected to the login screen. Must indicate the mandatory field to be corrected by the user. | <p>- Password min 8 characters and max 30<br>- All fields must be mandatory<br>- Email must be unique<br>- Display a confirmation message in case of success<br>- Password must contain at least one uppercase letter and one number</p> | User is created successfully with hashed password and proper validation |
| **User Authentication** | User enters email and password, system validates credentials and returns JWT tokens. Must handle invalid credentials and user status validation.                                                                       | <p>- Validate email format<br>- Check password strength<br>- Verify user status (ACTIVE/INACTIVE/BLOCKED)<br>- Return access and refresh tokens<br>- Handle case insensitive email</p>                                                   | User receives valid JWT tokens and can access protected endpoints       |
| **User Management**     | Administrator can create, update, delete, and list users with different roles and statuses.                                                                                                                            | <p>- CRUD operations for users<br>- Role-based permissions<br>- Status management (ACTIVE/INACTIVE/BLOCKED)<br>- Pagination support<br>- Soft delete functionality</p>                                                                   | All user management operations work correctly with proper permissions   |
| **Space Management**    | Create, update, delete, and list spaces with detailed information including photos, rules, amenities, and location.                                                                                                    | <p>- CRUD operations for spaces<br>- Photo upload and management<br>- Address and geolocation handling<br>- Host assignment<br>- Average rating calculation</p>                                                                          | Spaces are managed correctly with all associated data                   |
| **Appointment Booking** | Users can book spaces for specific dates and times with conflict detection and approval workflows.                                                                                                                     | <p>- Date and time validation<br>- Conflict detection<br>- Status management (PENDING/CONFIRMED/CANCELLED/REJECTED)<br>- Change tracking and limits<br>- Approval workflows</p>                                                          | Appointments are created and managed correctly with proper validation   |
| **Rating System**       | Users can rate spaces with scores from 1-5 and optional comments. Each user can rate a space only once.                                                                                                                | <p>- Score validation (1-5 range)<br>- Unique rating per user per space<br>- Comment optional<br>- Average rating calculation<br>- Rating update and deletion</p>                                                                        | Ratings are created and managed correctly with proper validation        |
| **RBAC System**         | Role-based access control with permission management and role assignments.                                                                                                                                             | <p>- Role creation and management<br>- Permission assignment<br>- User role assignment<br>- Expiration date handling<br>- Permission validation</p>                                                                                      | RBAC system works correctly with proper access control                  |
| **Notification System** | Send notifications via email, SMS, and push notifications using configurable templates.                                                                                                                                | <p>- Template management<br>- Multiple notification types<br>- Delivery status tracking<br>- Error handling<br>- User preferences</p>                                                                                                    | Notifications are sent correctly through all channels                   |
| **Health Check**        | System provides endpoints to check application status and connectivity.                                                                                                                                                | <p>- API health status<br>- Database connectivity<br>- Redis connectivity<br>- System uptime<br>- Environment information</p>                                                                                                            | Health check endpoints return correct status information                |

### 4. Environment and Tools

The tests will be conducted in the homologation environment, and it contains the same configurations as the production environment with a data mass previously generated by the quality team.

The following tools will be used in the test:

| Tool          | Team        | Description                          |
| ------------- | ----------- | ------------------------------------ |
| **Vitest**    | Development | Framework used for unit tests        |
| **Jest**      | Development | Framework used for integration tests |
| **Postman**   | Quality     | Tool for performing API tests        |
| **Selenium**  | Quality     | Tool for end-to-end tests            |
| **Cypress**   | Quality     | Tool for frontend testing            |
| **Supertest** | Development | Tool for API integration testing     |

### 5. Bug Classification

Bugs will be classified with the following severities:

| ID    | Severity Level | Description                                                                                                                                                                      |
| ----- | -------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **1** | **Blocker**    | <p>- Bug that blocks the test of a function or feature causes application crash<br>- Button does not work, preventing complete use of the functionality<br>- Blocks delivery</p> |
| **2** | **Severe**     | <p>- Functionality does not work as expected<br>- Unusual input causes irreversible effects<br>- Security vulnerabilities</p>                                                    |
| **3** | **Moderate**   | <p>- Functionality does not meet certain acceptance criteria, but its overall functionality is not affected<br>- Performance issues that don't block functionality</p>           |
| **4** | **Minor**      | <p>- Error or success message is not displayed<br>- Almost no impact on functionality, but hinders the user experience<br>- Typographical error<br>- Small UI errors</p>         |

### 6. Definition of Done

Functionalities will be considered ready that pass the verifications and tests described in this Test Plan, do not present bugs with severity above Minor, and pass a business validation under the responsibility of the product team.

### 7. Test Coverage by Module

#### 7.1 User Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                  | Expected Behavior                                                    | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                    | Acceptance Criteria                                       |
| -------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------------------- |
| **User Entity Creation**   | Should create a user with all required fields and generate unique ID | <p>- Validate all required fields (name, email, password)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify default status (ACTIVE)<br>- Verify default role (USER)<br>- Check createdAt timestamp</p> | User is created successfully with all fields properly set |
| **Password Hashing**       | Should hash password using bcrypt with salt                          | <p>- Password should be hashed with bcrypt<br>- Hash should start with $2a$, $2b$, or $2y$<br>- Password verification should work<br>- Original password should not be stored</p>                | Password is securely hashed and can be verified           |
| **User Status Management** | Should allow status changes between ACTIVE, INACTIVE, BLOCKED        | <p>- Status can be updated to all valid values<br>- updatedAt timestamp is updated<br>- Invalid status should throw error<br>- Status changes are persisted</p>                                  | User status can be changed and persisted correctly        |
| **User Role Management**   | Should allow role changes between ADMIN, MANAGER, USER               | <p>- Role can be updated to all valid values<br>- updatedAt timestamp is updated<br>- Invalid role should throw error<br>- Role changes are persisted</p>                                        | User role can be changed and persisted correctly          |
| **Email Uniqueness**       | Should prevent duplicate emails (case insensitive)                   | <p>- Email uniqueness is enforced<br>- Case insensitive comparison<br>- Error thrown for duplicate emails<br>- Valid emails are accepted</p>                                                     | Email uniqueness is properly enforced                     |
| **Soft Delete**            | Should mark user as deleted without removing from database           | <p>- deletedAt timestamp is set<br>- updatedAt timestamp is updated<br>- User remains in database<br>- Status remains unchanged</p>                                                              | User is soft deleted correctly                            |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case                   | Expected Behavior                                          | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                     | Acceptance Criteria                                       |
| --------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- |
| **CreateUserUseCase**       | Should create new user with hashed password and validation | <p>- User is created with all fields<br>- Password is hashed<br>- Email uniqueness is checked<br>- User count increases by 1<br>- Factory pattern works correctly</p>                                             | User is created successfully with proper validation       |
| **UpdateUserUseCase**       | Should update user fields and maintain data integrity      | <p>- Name can be updated<br>- Email can be updated (with uniqueness check)<br>- Status can be updated<br>- Role can be updated<br>- updatedAt is updated<br>- Non-modified fields remain unchanged</p>            | User updates work correctly with data integrity           |
| **DeleteUserUseCase**       | Should soft delete user and update status                  | <p>- User is marked as deleted<br>- Status becomes INACTIVE<br>- deletedAt timestamp is set<br>- Error thrown for non-existent user<br>- Multiple users can be deleted</p>                                        | User is soft deleted correctly                            |
| **FindUserByIdUseCase**     | Should find user by ID regardless of status                | <p>- Active user is found<br>- Inactive user is found<br>- Deleted user is found<br>- Null returned for non-existent user<br>- All user fields are returned</p>                                                   | User can be found by ID in all statuses                   |
| **FindUserByEmailUseCase**  | Should find user by email (case insensitive)               | <p>- User is found by email<br>- Case insensitive search works<br>- Null returned for non-existent email<br>- All user fields are returned<br>- Works with different statuses</p>                                 | User can be found by email correctly                      |
| **FindAllUsersUseCase**     | Should return paginated list of users                      | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no users<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes</p>                                                 | Users are listed with proper pagination                   |
| **CountUsersUseCase**       | Should count only active and non-deleted users             | <p>- Only active users are counted<br>- Deleted users are not counted<br>- Inactive users are not counted<br>- Returns 0 when no users<br>- Works with different roles</p>                                        | User count is accurate for active users                   |
| **AuthenticateUserUseCase** | Should authenticate user and return JWT tokens             | <p>- Valid credentials return tokens<br>- Invalid password throws error<br>- Non-existent email throws error<br>- Inactive user throws error<br>- Deleted user throws error<br>- Case insensitive email works</p> | Authentication works correctly with proper error handling |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                  | Expected Behavior                                   | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         | Acceptance Criteria                                |
| -------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------- |
| **InMemoryUserRepository** | Should provide in-memory user storage for testing   | <p>- User creation works<br>- User finding by ID works<br>- User finding by email works (case insensitive)<br>- User listing with pagination works<br>- User updating works<br>- User deletion (soft delete) works<br>- User counting works<br>- Handles multiple users correctly</p> | In-memory repository works correctly for testing   |
| **PrismaUserRepository**   | Should provide database user storage for production | <p>- User creation works with database<br>- User finding by ID works<br>- User finding by email works<br>- User listing with pagination works<br>- User updating works<br>- User deletion (soft delete) works<br>- User counting works<br>- Database transactions work correctly</p>  | Database repository works correctly for production |

#### 7.2 Space Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                   | Expected Behavior                                                     | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                            | Acceptance Criteria                                        |
| --------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Space Entity Creation**   | Should create a space with all required fields and generate unique ID | <p>- Validate all required fields (title, description, hostId)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify default values<br>- Check createdAt timestamp<br>- Handle optional fields (photos, rules)</p> | Space is created successfully with all fields properly set |
| **Address and Geolocation** | Should handle address information and geolocation data                | <p>- Address fields are stored correctly<br>- Latitude and longitude are validated<br>- Address formatting works<br>- Geolocation data is accurate<br>- Address updates work correctly</p>               | Address and geolocation data is handled properly           |
| **Photo Management**        | Should handle multiple photos for spaces                              | <p>- Photos array is stored correctly<br>- Photo URLs are validated<br>- Multiple photos are supported<br>- Photo updates work correctly<br>- Photo deletion works</p>                                   | Photo management works correctly                           |
| **Host Assignment**         | Should validate host assignment and permissions                       | <p>- Host ID is validated<br>- Host exists in system<br>- Host permissions are checked<br>- Host can manage their spaces<br>- Host changes work correctly</p>                                            | Host assignment and permissions work correctly             |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case                | Expected Behavior                                           | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                             | Acceptance Criteria                                  |
| ------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| **CreateSpaceUseCase**   | Should create new space with validation and host assignment | <p>- Space is created with all fields<br>- Host assignment is validated<br>- Photos are stored correctly<br>- Rules are optional<br>- Factory pattern works correctly<br>- Space count increases by 1</p> | Space is created successfully with proper validation |
| **UpdateSpaceUseCase**   | Should update space fields and maintain data integrity      | <p>- Title can be updated<br>- Description can be updated<br>- Photos can be updated<br>- Rules can be updated<br>- updatedAt is updated<br>- Non-modified fields remain unchanged</p>                    | Space updates work correctly with data integrity     |
| **DeleteSpaceUseCase**   | Should delete space and handle related data                 | <p>- Space is deleted<br>- Related appointments are handled<br>- Related ratings are handled<br>- Error thrown for non-existent space<br>- Multiple spaces can be deleted</p>                             | Space is deleted correctly with proper cleanup       |
| **FindSpaceByIdUseCase** | Should find space by ID with all details                    | <p>- Space is found by ID<br>- All space fields are returned<br>- Null returned for non-existent space<br>- Photos are included<br>- Average rating is calculated</p>                                     | Space can be found by ID with complete details       |
| **FindAllSpacesUseCase** | Should return paginated list of spaces                      | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no spaces<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes<br>- Includes average ratings</p>          | Spaces are listed with proper pagination             |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                    | Expected Behavior                                  | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                          | Acceptance Criteria                              |
| ---------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ |
| **InMemorySpacesRepository** | Should provide in-memory space storage for testing | <p>- Space creation works<br>- Space finding by ID works<br>- Space listing with pagination works<br>- Space updating works<br>- Space deletion works<br>- Handles multiple spaces correctly<br>- Average rating calculation works</p> | In-memory repository works correctly for testing |

#### 7.3 Appointment Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                       | Expected Behavior                                                    | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   | Acceptance Criteria                                        |
| ------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Appointment Entity Creation** | Should create an appointment with all required fields and validation | <p>- Validate all required fields (userId, spaceId, date, startTime, endTime)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify default status (PENDING)<br>- Check createdAt timestamp<br>- Validate date is not in past</p>                                         | Appointment is created successfully with proper validation |
| **Date and Time Validation**    | Should validate appointment dates and times                          | <p>- Date cannot be in the past<br>- Start time must be before end time<br>- Time format is validated<br>- Date format is validated<br>- Timezone handling works correctly</p>                                                                                  | Date and time validation works correctly                   |
| **Conflict Detection**          | Should detect scheduling conflicts for same space                    | <p>- No conflicts for different spaces at same time<br>- Conflicts detected for same space at overlapping times<br>- Edge cases handled (exact start/end times)<br>- Cancelled appointments don't cause conflicts<br>- Multiple conflicts handled correctly</p> | Conflict detection works accurately                        |
| **Status Management**           | Should handle appointment status transitions                         | <p>- Status can be PENDING, CONFIRMED, CANCELLED, REJECTED<br>- Status transitions are validated<br>- Status changes are logged<br>- Status affects conflict detection<br>- Status updates work correctly</p>                                                   | Status management works correctly                          |
| **Change Tracking**             | Should track appointment changes and limits                          | <p>- Change count is tracked<br>- Change limits are enforced (3 for USER/MANAGER, unlimited for ADMIN)<br>- Change history is maintained<br>- 2-month rescheduling limit is enforced<br>- Change tracking works correctly</p>                                   | Change tracking and limits work correctly                  |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case                            | Expected Behavior                                                    | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                   | Acceptance Criteria                                        |
| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| **CreateAppointmentUseCase**         | Should create new appointment with conflict detection and validation | <p>- Appointment is created with all fields<br>- User and space existence is validated<br>- Date and time validation works<br>- Conflict detection works<br>- Status is set to PENDING<br>- Factory pattern works correctly</p> | Appointment is created successfully with proper validation |
| **UpdateAppointmentUseCase**         | Should update appointment with validation and change tracking        | <p>- Date and time can be updated<br>- Status can be updated<br>- Change tracking works<br>- Change limits are enforced<br>- Validation works for updates<br>- Non-modified fields remain unchanged</p>                         | Appointment updates work correctly with validation         |
| **DeleteAppointmentUseCase**         | Should delete appointment and handle cleanup                         | <p>- Appointment is deleted<br>- Error thrown for non-existent appointment<br>- Works with different statuses<br>- Multiple appointments can be deleted<br>- Cleanup is handled correctly</p>                                   | Appointment is deleted correctly                           |
| **FindAppointmentByIdUseCase**       | Should find appointment by ID with all details                       | <p>- Appointment is found by ID<br>- All appointment fields are returned<br>- Error thrown for non-existent appointment<br>- Works with different statuses<br>- Complete appointment data is returned</p>                       | Appointment can be found by ID with complete details       |
| **FindAppointmentsByUserIdUseCase**  | Should return paginated list of user appointments                    | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no appointments<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes<br>- Includes all appointment details</p>                  | User appointments are listed with proper pagination        |
| **FindAppointmentsBySpaceIdUseCase** | Should return paginated list of space appointments                   | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no appointments<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes<br>- Includes all appointment details</p>                  | Space appointments are listed with proper pagination       |
| **ApproveAppointmentUseCase**        | Should approve appointment and send notifications                    | <p>- Status changes to CONFIRMED<br>- Notification is sent to user<br>- Approval is logged<br>- Works with proper permissions<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>                                                           | Appointment approval works correctly                       |
| **RejectAppointmentUseCase**         | Should reject appointment and send notifications                     | <p>- Status changes to REJECTED<br>- Notification is sent to user<br>- Rejection is logged<br>- Works with proper permissions<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>                                                           | Appointment rejection works correctly                      |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                         | Expected Behavior                                        | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | Acceptance Criteria                              |
| --------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ |
| **InMemoryAppointmentRepository** | Should provide in-memory appointment storage for testing | <p>- Appointment creation works<br>- Appointment finding by ID works<br>- Appointment listing with pagination works<br>- Appointment updating works<br>- Appointment deletion works<br>- Conflict detection works<br>- Change tracking works<br>- Handles multiple appointments correctly</p> | In-memory repository works correctly for testing |

#### 7.4 Rating Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                      | Expected Behavior                                              | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                  | Acceptance Criteria                                   |
| ------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- |
| **Rating Entity Creation**     | Should create a rating with all required fields and validation | <p>- Validate all required fields (userId, spaceId, score)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify score range (1-5)<br>- Check createdAt timestamp<br>- Handle optional comment field</p> | Rating is created successfully with proper validation |
| **Score Validation**           | Should validate rating score within 1-5 range                  | <p>- Score must be between 1 and 5<br>- Integer scores are accepted<br>- Decimal scores are rejected<br>- Zero and negative scores are rejected<br>- Scores above 5 are rejected</p>           | Score validation works correctly                      |
| **Comment Handling**           | Should handle optional comment field                           | <p>- Comment is optional<br>- Comment can be empty string<br>- Comment can be null<br>- Comment length is validated<br>- Comment updates work correctly</p>                                    | Comment handling works correctly                      |
| **Average Rating Calculation** | Should calculate average rating for spaces                     | <p>- Average is calculated correctly<br>- Decimal places are handled<br>- Zero ratings return 0<br>- Single rating returns that rating<br>- Multiple ratings average correctly</p>             | Average rating calculation works accurately           |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case                        | Expected Behavior                                         | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                          | Acceptance Criteria                                   |
| -------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- |
| **CreateRatingUseCase**          | Should create new rating with validation and space update | <p>- Rating is created with all fields<br>- Score validation works (1-5)<br>- Comment is optional<br>- Space average rating is updated<br>- User can only rate once per space<br>- Factory pattern works correctly</p> | Rating is created successfully with proper validation |
| **UpdateRatingUseCase**          | Should update rating with validation and space update     | <p>- Score can be updated (1-5)<br>- Comment can be updated<br>- Space average rating is recalculated<br>- Validation works for updates<br>- Non-modified fields remain unchanged</p>                                  | Rating updates work correctly with validation         |
| **DeleteRatingUseCase**          | Should delete rating and update space average             | <p>- Rating is deleted<br>- Space average rating is recalculated<br>- Error thrown for non-existent rating<br>- Works with different scores<br>- Multiple ratings can be deleted</p>                                   | Rating is deleted correctly with space update         |
| **FindRatingByIdUseCase**        | Should find rating by ID with all details                 | <p>- Rating is found by ID<br>- All rating fields are returned<br>- Null returned for non-existent rating<br>- Complete rating data is returned<br>- Works with different scores</p>                                   | Rating can be found by ID with complete details       |
| **FindRatingsBySpaceIdUseCase**  | Should return paginated list of space ratings             | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no ratings<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes<br>- Includes all rating details</p>                   | Space ratings are listed with proper pagination       |
| **FindRatingsByUserIdUseCase**   | Should return paginated list of user ratings              | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no ratings<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes<br>- Includes all rating details</p>                   | User ratings are listed with proper pagination        |
| **GetSpaceAverageRatingUseCase** | Should return average rating for a space                  | <p>- Average is calculated correctly<br>- Returns 0 when no ratings<br>- Handles decimal averages<br>- Works with single rating<br>- Works with multiple ratings</p>                                                   | Space average rating is calculated correctly          |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                    | Expected Behavior                                   | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             | Acceptance Criteria                              |
| ---------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ |
| **InMemoryRatingRepository** | Should provide in-memory rating storage for testing | <p>- Rating creation works<br>- Rating finding by ID works<br>- Rating listing with pagination works<br>- Rating updating works<br>- Rating deletion works<br>- Average calculation works<br>- Handles multiple ratings correctly<br>- Space and user filtering works</p> | In-memory repository works correctly for testing |

#### 7.5 Authentication Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                 | Expected Behavior                                    | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                    | Acceptance Criteria                           |
| ------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- |
| **JWT Token Generation**  | Should generate valid JWT tokens with proper payload | <p>- Access token is generated<br>- Refresh token is generated<br>- Tokens contain correct payload<br>- Tokens have proper expiration<br>- Tokens are signed correctly</p>       | JWT tokens are generated correctly            |
| **JWT Token Validation**  | Should validate JWT tokens and extract payload       | <p>- Valid tokens are accepted<br>- Invalid tokens are rejected<br>- Expired tokens are rejected<br>- Malformed tokens are rejected<br>- Payload extraction works correctly</p>  | JWT token validation works correctly          |
| **Password Verification** | Should verify passwords against hashed values        | <p>- Correct password is verified<br>- Incorrect password is rejected<br>- Hash comparison works correctly<br>- Salt handling works correctly<br>- Performance is acceptable</p> | Password verification works correctly         |
| **Token Blacklist**       | Should manage blacklisted tokens                     | <p>- Tokens can be blacklisted<br>- Blacklisted tokens are rejected<br>- Token expiration is handled<br>- Blacklist cleanup works<br>- Multiple tokens can be blacklisted</p>    | Token blacklist functionality works correctly |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case               | Expected Behavior                               | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        | Acceptance Criteria                                       |
| ----------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- |
| **AuthenticateUseCase** | Should authenticate user and return JWT tokens  | <p>- Valid credentials return tokens<br>- Invalid password throws error<br>- Non-existent email throws error<br>- Inactive user throws error<br>- Deleted user throws error<br>- Case insensitive email works<br>- Tokens are properly formatted</p> | Authentication works correctly with proper error handling |
| **RefreshTokenUseCase** | Should refresh access token using refresh token | <p>- Valid refresh token generates new tokens<br>- Invalid refresh token throws error<br>- Expired refresh token throws error<br>- Revoked refresh token throws error<br>- New tokens are different from old ones<br>- Refresh token is rotated</p>  | Token refresh works correctly                             |
| **LogoutUseCase**       | Should logout user and blacklist tokens         | <p>- Access token is blacklisted<br>- Refresh token is invalidated<br>- User session is terminated<br>- Blacklist is updated<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>                                                                                 | Logout functionality works correctly                      |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                            | Expected Behavior                                            | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                  | Acceptance Criteria                                  |
| ------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| **InMemoryRefreshTokenRepository**   | Should provide in-memory refresh token storage for testing   | <p>- Refresh token storage works<br>- Token retrieval works<br>- Token deletion works<br>- Token validation works<br>- Expiration handling works<br>- Handles multiple tokens correctly</p>    | In-memory refresh token repository works correctly   |
| **InMemoryTokenBlacklistRepository** | Should provide in-memory token blacklist storage for testing | <p>- Token blacklisting works<br>- Blacklist checking works<br>- Token removal works<br>- Expiration cleanup works<br>- Handles multiple blacklisted tokens<br>- Performance is acceptable</p> | In-memory token blacklist repository works correctly |

#### 7.6 RBAC Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                      | Expected Behavior                                            | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                        | Acceptance Criteria                                       |
| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Role Entity Creation**       | Should create a role with all required fields and validation | <p>- Validate all required fields (name, description)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify role name uniqueness<br>- Check createdAt timestamp<br>- Handle optional description field</p>                     | Role is created successfully with proper validation       |
| **Permission Entity Creation** | Should create a permission with resource:operation format    | <p>- Validate all required fields (resource, operation)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify permission format (resource:operation)<br>- Check createdAt timestamp<br>- Handle optional description field</p> | Permission is created successfully with proper validation |
| **Role Assignment Validation** | Should validate role assignments to users                    | <p>- User existence is validated<br>- Role existence is validated<br>- Duplicate assignments are prevented<br>- Expiration dates are handled<br>- Assignment permissions are checked</p>                             | Role assignment validation works correctly                |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case                     | Expected Behavior                             | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                  | Acceptance Criteria                             |
| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------- |
| **AssignRoleUseCase**         | Should assign role to user with validation    | <p>- Role is assigned to user<br>- User and role existence is validated<br>- Duplicate assignments are prevented<br>- Expiration date is handled<br>- Assignment is logged<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>             | Role assignment works correctly with validation |
| **RevokeRoleUseCase**         | Should revoke role from user                  | <p>- Role is revoked from user<br>- User and role existence is validated<br>- Revocation is logged<br>- Error handling works correctly<br>- Works with different roles<br>- Multiple revocations work</p>                      | Role revocation works correctly                 |
| **GetRolesUseCase**           | Should return list of available roles         | <p>- All roles are returned<br>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Role details are complete<br>- Empty list when no roles<br>- Works with different page sizes</p>                                                              | Roles are listed correctly                      |
| **GetUserPermissionsUseCase** | Should return user permissions based on roles | <p>- User permissions are calculated<br>- Role-based permissions are included<br>- Permission format is correct<br>- Duplicate permissions are removed<br>- Works with multiple roles<br>- Empty permissions when no roles</p> | User permissions are calculated correctly       |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                        | Expected Behavior                                                 | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          | Acceptance Criteria                             |
| -------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------- |
| **InMemoryRoleRepository**       | Should provide in-memory role storage for testing                 | <p>- Role creation works<br>- Role finding by ID works<br>- Role listing works<br>- Role updating works<br>- Role deletion works<br>- Handles multiple roles correctly<br>- Role name uniqueness works</p>                                             | In-memory role repository works correctly       |
| **InMemoryPermissionRepository** | Should provide in-memory permission storage for testing           | <p>- Permission creation works<br>- Permission finding by ID works<br>- Permission listing works<br>- Permission updating works<br>- Permission deletion works<br>- Handles multiple permissions correctly<br>- Permission format validation works</p> | In-memory permission repository works correctly |
| **InMemoryUserRoleRepository**   | Should provide in-memory user-role assignment storage for testing | <p>- Role assignment works<br>- Role revocation works<br>- User roles listing works<br>- Assignment validation works<br>- Expiration handling works<br>- Handles multiple assignments correctly<br>- Duplicate prevention works</p>                    | In-memory user-role repository works correctly  |

#### 7.7 Notification Module

**Unit Tests**

| Test Case                          | Expected Behavior                                   | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                             | Acceptance Criteria                                         |
| ---------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Notification Template Creation** | Should create notification templates with variables | <p>- Template creation works<br>- Variable substitution works<br>- Template validation works<br>- Template format is correct<br>- Template updates work correctly</p>                     | Notification templates are created correctly                |
| **Notification Entity Creation**   | Should create notification with all required fields | <p>- Validate all required fields (type, recipient, content)<br>- Check unique ID generation<br>- Verify notification type<br>- Check createdAt timestamp<br>- Handle delivery status</p> | Notification is created successfully with proper validation |
| **Delivery Status Tracking**       | Should track notification delivery status           | <p>- Status can be PENDING, SENT, FAILED<br>- Status transitions are tracked<br>- Delivery attempts are logged<br>- Error handling works correctly<br>- Status updates work correctly</p> | Delivery status tracking works correctly                    |

**Use Case Tests**

| Test Case                      | Expected Behavior                                      | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                             | Acceptance Criteria                                   |
| ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- |
| **SendNotificationUseCase**    | Should send notification through multiple channels     | <p>- Email notifications are sent<br>- SMS notifications are sent<br>- Push notifications are sent<br>- Template substitution works<br>- Delivery status is tracked<br>- Error handling works correctly<br>- Multiple recipients work</p> | Notifications are sent correctly through all channels |
| **ListNotificationsUseCase**   | Should return paginated list of notifications          | <p>- Pagination works correctly<br>- Total count is accurate<br>- Empty list when no notifications<br>- Correct page is returned<br>- Works with different page sizes<br>- Includes delivery status</p>                                   | Notifications are listed with proper pagination       |
| **GetNotificationByIdUseCase** | Should find notification by ID with all details        | <p>- Notification is found by ID<br>- All notification fields are returned<br>- Error thrown for non-existent notification<br>- Complete notification data is returned<br>- Delivery status is included</p>                               | Notification can be found by ID with complete details |
| **ListTemplatesUseCase**       | Should return list of available notification templates | <p>- All templates are returned<br>- Template details are complete<br>- Template variables are included<br>- Empty list when no templates<br>- Template categories work correctly</p>                                                     | Notification templates are listed correctly           |

**Repository Tests**

| Test Case                          | Expected Behavior                                         | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  | Acceptance Criteria                               |
| ---------------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------- |
| **InMemoryNotificationRepository** | Should provide in-memory notification storage for testing | <p>- Notification creation works<br>- Notification finding by ID works<br>- Notification listing with pagination works<br>- Notification updating works<br>- Notification deletion works<br>- Delivery status tracking works<br>- Handles multiple notifications correctly</p> | In-memory notification repository works correctly |

### 8. Integration Tests

#### 8.1 API Endpoint Tests

| Test Case                        | Expected Behavior                                     | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      | Acceptance Criteria                         |
| -------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- |
| **User Endpoints (CRUD)**        | Should handle all user operations via REST API        | <p>- POST /users creates user<br>- GET /users lists users with pagination<br>- GET /users/:id finds user by ID<br>- PUT /users/:id updates user<br>- DELETE /users/:id soft deletes user<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Request/response validation works</p>                                                                  | User API endpoints work correctly           |
| **Space Endpoints (CRUD)**       | Should handle all space operations via REST API       | <p>- POST /spaces creates space<br>- GET /spaces lists spaces with pagination<br>- GET /spaces/:id finds space by ID<br>- PUT /spaces/:id updates space<br>- DELETE /spaces/:id deletes space<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Request/response validation works</p>                                                             | Space API endpoints work correctly          |
| **Appointment Endpoints (CRUD)** | Should handle all appointment operations via REST API | <p>- POST /appointments creates appointment<br>- GET /appointments lists appointments with pagination<br>- GET /appointments/:id finds appointment by ID<br>- PUT /appointments/:id updates appointment<br>- DELETE /appointments/:id deletes appointment<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Request/response validation works</p> | Appointment API endpoints work correctly    |
| **Rating Endpoints (CRUD)**      | Should handle all rating operations via REST API      | <p>- POST /ratings creates rating<br>- GET /ratings lists ratings with pagination<br>- GET /ratings/:id finds rating by ID<br>- PUT /ratings/:id updates rating<br>- DELETE /ratings/:id deletes rating<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Request/response validation works</p>                                                   | Rating API endpoints work correctly         |
| **Authentication Endpoints**     | Should handle authentication operations via REST API  | <p>- POST /auth/login authenticates user<br>- POST /auth/refresh refreshes tokens<br>- POST /auth/logout logs out user<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- JWT token handling works<br>- Error responses are correct</p>                                                                                                            | Authentication API endpoints work correctly |
| **RBAC Endpoints**               | Should handle role-based access control via REST API  | <p>- POST /rbac/assign assigns role to user<br>- DELETE /rbac/revoke revokes role from user<br>- GET /rbac/roles lists available roles<br>- GET /rbac/permissions gets user permissions<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Authorization works correctly</p>                                                                       | RBAC API endpoints work correctly           |
| **Notification Endpoints**       | Should handle notification operations via REST API    | <p>- POST /notifications/send sends notification<br>- GET /notifications lists notifications<br>- GET /notifications/:id finds notification by ID<br>- GET /notifications/templates lists templates<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Request/response validation works</p>                                                       | Notification API endpoints work correctly   |
| **Health Check Endpoints**       | Should provide system health information              | <p>- GET /health returns system status<br>- GET /health/db returns database status<br>- GET /health/redis returns Redis status<br>- Proper HTTP status codes<br>- Response includes relevant metrics</p>                                                                                                                           | Health check endpoints work correctly       |

#### 8.2 Database Integration Tests

| Test Case                  | Expected Behavior                                  | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                 | Acceptance Criteria                   |
| -------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- |
| **PostgreSQL Connection**  | Should establish and maintain database connections | <p>- Connection is established successfully<br>- Connection pool works correctly<br>- Connection errors are handled<br>- Connection timeouts work<br>- Connection recovery works</p>                                          | Database connections work correctly   |
| **PostgreSQL Queries**     | Should execute database queries correctly          | <p>- SELECT queries return correct data<br>- INSERT queries create records<br>- UPDATE queries modify records<br>- DELETE queries remove records<br>- Complex queries work correctly<br>- Query performance is acceptable</p> | Database queries work correctly       |
| **Redis Cache Operations** | Should handle Redis cache operations               | <p>- Cache SET operations work<br>- Cache GET operations work<br>- Cache DELETE operations work<br>- Cache expiration works<br>- Cache keys are managed correctly<br>- Cache performance is acceptable</p>                    | Redis cache operations work correctly |
| **Data Persistence**       | Should persist data correctly across operations    | <p>- Data is saved to database<br>- Data is retrieved correctly<br>- Data integrity is maintained<br>- Transaction rollback works<br>- Data consistency is preserved</p>                                                      | Data persistence works correctly      |
| **Transaction Handling**   | Should handle database transactions correctly      | <p>- Transactions are started correctly<br>- Transactions are committed successfully<br>- Transactions are rolled back on errors<br>- Nested transactions work<br>- Transaction isolation levels work</p>                     | Transaction handling works correctly  |

#### 8.3 External Service Integration Tests

| Test Case                       | Expected Behavior                                       | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                      | Acceptance Criteria                                   |
| ------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- |
| **Email Service Integration**   | Should send emails through external service             | <p>- Email is sent successfully<br>- Email content is correct<br>- Email recipients are correct<br>- Email templates work<br>- Email delivery status is tracked<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>                            | Email service integration works correctly             |
| **SMS Service Integration**     | Should send SMS through external service                | <p>- SMS is sent successfully<br>- SMS content is correct<br>- SMS recipients are correct<br>- SMS templates work<br>- SMS delivery status is tracked<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>                                      | SMS service integration works correctly               |
| **Push Notification Service**   | Should send push notifications through external service | <p>- Push notification is sent successfully<br>- Notification content is correct<br>- Device tokens are handled correctly<br>- Notification templates work<br>- Delivery status is tracked<br>- Error handling works correctly</p> | Push notification service integration works correctly |
| **Payment Service Integration** | Should handle payment processing (if applicable)        | <p>- Payment processing works<br>- Payment validation works<br>- Payment status tracking works<br>- Refund processing works<br>- Payment security is maintained<br>- Error handling works correctly</p>                            | Payment service integration works correctly           |

### 9. End-to-End Tests

#### 9.1 User Journey Tests

| Test Case                                     | Expected Behavior                                        | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                | Acceptance Criteria                                  |
| --------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| **Complete User Registration and Login Flow** | Should allow new user to register and login successfully | <p>- User fills registration form<br>- User data is validated<br>- User is created in database<br>- Email confirmation is sent<br>- User can login with credentials<br>- JWT tokens are generated<br>- User is redirected to dashboard</p>                   | Complete user registration and login works correctly |
| **Space Booking Workflow**                    | Should allow user to book a space successfully           | <p>- User browses available spaces<br>- User selects a space<br>- User fills booking form<br>- Date and time validation works<br>- Conflict detection works<br>- Booking is created<br>- Confirmation is sent to user<br>- Space availability is updated</p> | Space booking workflow works correctly               |
| **Rating Submission Process**                 | Should allow user to rate a space after booking          | <p>- User can access rating form<br>- Rating validation works (1-5)<br>- Comment is optional<br>- Rating is saved to database<br>- Space average rating is updated<br>- User can only rate once per space<br>- Rating confirmation is shown</p>              | Rating submission process works correctly            |
| **Admin User Management Workflow**            | Should allow admin to manage users effectively           | <p>- Admin can view all users<br>- Admin can create new users<br>- Admin can update user details<br>- Admin can change user status<br>- Admin can assign roles<br>- Admin can delete users<br>- Changes are reflected immediately</p>                        | Admin user management workflow works correctly       |
| **Manager Space Approval Workflow**           | Should allow manager to approve space bookings           | <p>- Manager can view pending bookings<br>- Manager can approve bookings<br>- Manager can reject bookings<br>- Notifications are sent to users<br>- Booking status is updated<br>- Space availability is managed<br>- Approval history is maintained</p>     | Manager space approval workflow works correctly      |

#### 9.2 Cross-Module Integration Tests

| Test Case                                               | Expected Behavior                                     | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     | Acceptance Criteria                                        |
| ------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- |
| **User Creates Appointment and Receives Notification**  | Should send notification when appointment is created  | <p>- User creates appointment<br>- Appointment is saved to database<br>- Notification is triggered<br>- Email notification is sent<br>- SMS notification is sent (if enabled)<br>- Push notification is sent (if enabled)<br>- Notification status is tracked</p> | Cross-module notification integration works correctly      |
| **Manager Approves Appointment and User Gets Notified** | Should send notification when appointment is approved | <p>- Manager approves appointment<br>- Appointment status is updated<br>- Notification is triggered<br>- User receives approval notification<br>- Email content is correct<br>- Notification delivery is tracked<br>- User can view updated status</p>            | Approval notification integration works correctly          |
| **User Rates Space and Average Rating Updates**         | Should update space average rating when user rates    | <p>- User submits rating<br>- Rating is saved to database<br>- Space average rating is recalculated<br>- Space record is updated<br>- Rating count is updated<br>- Average is displayed correctly<br>- Rating history is maintained</p>                           | Rating integration with space updates works correctly      |
| **Admin Assigns Role and User Gets New Permissions**    | Should update user permissions when role is assigned  | <p>- Admin assigns role to user<br>- Role assignment is saved<br>- User permissions are recalculated<br>- Permission cache is updated<br>- User can access new features<br>- Role assignment is logged<br>- Permission changes are immediate</p>                  | Role assignment and permission integration works correctly |

### 10. Performance Tests

#### 10.1 Load Tests

| Test Case                               | Expected Behavior                                           | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         | Acceptance Criteria                                  |
| --------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| **API Response Time Under Normal Load** | Should maintain acceptable response times under normal load | <p>- Response time < 200ms for simple operations<br>- Response time < 500ms for complex operations<br>- Response time < 1000ms for heavy operations<br>- 95th percentile response time is acceptable<br>- Response time consistency is maintained</p> | API performance meets requirements under normal load |
| **Database Query Performance**          | Should execute database queries efficiently                 | <p>- Simple queries execute in < 50ms<br>- Complex queries execute in < 200ms<br>- Query optimization is effective<br>- Database indexes are utilized<br>- Query caching works correctly<br>- Database connection pooling works</p>                   | Database query performance meets requirements        |
| **Concurrent User Handling**            | Should handle multiple concurrent users effectively         | <p>- System supports 100+ concurrent users<br>- Response times remain acceptable<br>- No data corruption occurs<br>- Session management works correctly<br>- Resource usage is reasonable<br>- System stability is maintained</p>                     | Concurrent user handling works correctly             |
| **Memory Usage Monitoring**             | Should monitor and manage memory usage effectively          | <p>- Memory usage is tracked<br>- Memory leaks are detected<br>- Garbage collection works correctly<br>- Memory usage is optimized<br>- Memory alerts are triggered<br>- Memory cleanup works correctly</p>                                           | Memory usage monitoring works correctly              |

#### 10.2 Stress Tests

| Test Case                             | Expected Behavior                               | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                    | Acceptance Criteria                              |
| ------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ |
| **Maximum Concurrent Users**          | Should determine system capacity limits         | <p>- System handles maximum load<br>- Performance degrades gracefully<br>- Error rates remain acceptable<br>- System doesn't crash<br>- Recovery mechanisms work<br>- Capacity planning data is collected</p>                    | System capacity limits are determined correctly  |
| **Database Connection Limits**        | Should handle database connection limits        | <p>- Connection pool limits are respected<br>- Connection timeouts work correctly<br>- Connection errors are handled<br>- Connection recovery works<br>- Database performance is maintained<br>- Connection monitoring works</p> | Database connection limits are handled correctly |
| **Memory and CPU Usage Under Stress** | Should manage resources under stress conditions | <p>- CPU usage is monitored<br>- Memory usage is controlled<br>- Resource exhaustion is prevented<br>- Performance degradation is gradual<br>- System stability is maintained<br>- Resource cleanup works</p>                    | Resource management under stress works correctly |
| **Recovery After High Load**          | Should recover gracefully after high load       | <p>- System recovers automatically<br>- Performance returns to normal<br>- Data integrity is maintained<br>- Services restart correctly<br>- Monitoring systems work<br>- Error rates return to normal</p>                       | System recovery after high load works correctly  |

### 11. Security Tests

#### 11.1 Authentication Tests

| Test Case                          | Expected Behavior                       | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                        | Acceptance Criteria                         |
| ---------------------------------- | --------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------- |
| **JWT Token Validation**           | Should validate JWT tokens securely     | <p>- Valid tokens are accepted<br>- Invalid tokens are rejected<br>- Expired tokens are rejected<br>- Malformed tokens are rejected<br>- Token signature verification works<br>- Token payload validation works</p>                  | JWT token validation works securely         |
| **Password Strength Requirements** | Should enforce strong password policies | <p>- Minimum 8 characters required<br>- Maximum 30 characters allowed<br>- At least one uppercase letter required<br>- At least one number required<br>- Special characters are allowed<br>- Password validation works correctly</p> | Password strength requirements are enforced |
| **Account Lockout Mechanisms**     | Should prevent brute force attacks      | <p>- Account is locked after failed attempts<br>- Lockout duration is enforced<br>- Lockout counter resets after success<br>- Admin can unlock accounts<br>- Lockout notifications are sent<br>- Failed attempt tracking works</p>   | Account lockout mechanisms work correctly   |
| **Session Management**             | Should manage user sessions securely    | <p>- Sessions are created correctly<br>- Sessions expire properly<br>- Sessions are invalidated on logout<br>- Session data is protected<br>- Concurrent sessions are handled<br>- Session cleanup works correctly</p>               | Session management works securely           |

#### 11.2 Authorization Tests

| Test Case                     | Expected Behavior                                | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                  | Acceptance Criteria                       |
| ----------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------- |
| **Role-Based Access Control** | Should enforce role-based permissions            | <p>- User roles are validated<br>- Role permissions are enforced<br>- Access is denied for unauthorized roles<br>- Role changes are immediate<br>- Role inheritance works correctly<br>- Role validation works correctly</p>   | Role-based access control works correctly |
| **Permission Validation**     | Should validate user permissions for actions     | <p>- Permission checks work correctly<br>- Resource access is controlled<br>- Operation permissions are enforced<br>- Permission caching works<br>- Permission updates are immediate<br>- Permission inheritance works</p>     | Permission validation works correctly     |
| **API Endpoint Protection**   | Should protect API endpoints with authentication | <p>- Protected endpoints require authentication<br>- Unauthorized access is blocked<br>- Token validation works<br>- Permission checks work<br>- Error responses are secure<br>- Rate limiting works</p>                       | API endpoint protection works correctly   |
| **Data Access Restrictions**  | Should restrict data access based on permissions | <p>- Users can only access authorized data<br>- Data filtering works correctly<br>- Cross-user data access is prevented<br>- Admin access is properly controlled<br>- Data privacy is maintained<br>- Access logging works</p> | Data access restrictions work correctly   |

#### 11.3 Input Validation Tests

| Test Case                    | Expected Behavior                           | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                              | Acceptance Criteria                      |
| ---------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------- |
| **SQL Injection Prevention** | Should prevent SQL injection attacks        | <p>- Malicious SQL is rejected<br>- Parameterized queries work<br>- Input sanitization works<br>- Database queries are safe<br>- Error messages don't leak data<br>- SQL injection attempts are logged</p> | SQL injection prevention works correctly |
| **XSS Protection**           | Should prevent cross-site scripting attacks | <p>- Malicious scripts are sanitized<br>- HTML encoding works correctly<br>- Script tags are blocked<br>- Event handlers are sanitized<br>- XSS attempts are logged<br>- Content security policy works</p> | XSS protection works correctly           |
| **Input Sanitization**       | Should sanitize all user inputs             | <p>- Special characters are handled<br>- HTML entities are encoded<br>- Script content is removed<br>- Input length is validated<br>- Input format is validated<br>- Sanitization is consistent</p>        | Input sanitization works correctly       |
| **File Upload Security**     | Should secure file upload functionality     | <p>- File type validation works<br>- File size limits are enforced<br>- Malicious files are rejected<br>- File storage is secure<br>- File access is controlled<br>- Upload logging works correctly</p>    | File upload security works correctly     |

### 12. Test Data Management

#### 12.1 Test Factories

| Test Case                     | Expected Behavior                                               | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       | Acceptance Criteria                                    |
| ----------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------ |
| **makeUser() Factory**        | Should create user entities with customizable properties        | <p>- User is created with default values<br>- Custom properties override defaults<br>- All user fields are properly set<br>- User ID is generated correctly<br>- Password is hashed correctly<br>- User validation works<br>- Factory is reusable</p>                               | User factory creates valid user entities               |
| **makeSpace() Factory**       | Should create space entities with customizable properties       | <p>- Space is created with default values<br>- Custom properties override defaults<br>- All space fields are properly set<br>- Space ID is generated correctly<br>- Photos array is handled correctly<br>- Space validation works<br>- Factory is reusable</p>                      | Space factory creates valid space entities             |
| **makeAppointment() Factory** | Should create appointment entities with customizable properties | <p>- Appointment is created with default values<br>- Custom properties override defaults<br>- All appointment fields are properly set<br>- Appointment ID is generated correctly<br>- Date and time validation works<br>- Appointment validation works<br>- Factory is reusable</p> | Appointment factory creates valid appointment entities |
| **makeRating() Factory**      | Should create rating entities with customizable properties      | <p>- Rating is created with default values<br>- Custom properties override defaults<br>- All rating fields are properly set<br>- Rating ID is generated correctly<br>- Score validation works (1-5)<br>- Rating validation works<br>- Factory is reusable</p>                       | Rating factory creates valid rating entities           |

#### 12.2 Test Repositories

| Test Case                         | Expected Behavior                                        | Verifications                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    | Acceptance Criteria                                          |
| --------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------ |
| **InMemoryUserRepository**        | Should provide in-memory user storage for testing        | <p>- User creation works correctly<br>- User retrieval by ID works<br>- User retrieval by email works<br>- User listing with pagination works<br>- User updating works<br>- User deletion (soft delete) works<br>- User counting works<br>- Handles multiple users correctly</p> | In-memory user repository works correctly for testing        |
| **InMemorySpaceRepository**       | Should provide in-memory space storage for testing       | <p>- Space creation works correctly<br>- Space retrieval by ID works<br>- Space listing with pagination works<br>- Space updating works<br>- Space deletion works<br>- Average rating calculation works<br>- Handles multiple spaces correctly</p>                               | In-memory space repository works correctly for testing       |
| **InMemoryAppointmentRepository** | Should provide in-memory appointment storage for testing | <p>- Appointment creation works correctly<br>- Appointment retrieval by ID works<br>- Appointment listing with pagination works<br>- Appointment updating works<br>- Appointment deletion works<br>- Conflict detection works<br>- Handles multiple appointments correctly</p>   | In-memory appointment repository works correctly for testing |
| **InMemoryRatingRepository**      | Should provide in-memory rating storage for testing      | <p>- Rating creation works correctly<br>- Rating retrieval by ID works<br>- Rating listing with pagination works<br>- Rating updating works<br>- Rating deletion works<br>- Average calculation works<br>- Handles multiple ratings correctly</p>                                | In-memory rating repository works correctly for testing      |
| **InMemoryRoleRepository**        | Should provide in-memory role storage for testing        | <p>- Role creation works correctly<br>- Role retrieval by ID works<br>- Role listing works<br>- Role updating works<br>- Role deletion works<br>- Role name uniqueness works<br>- Handles multiple roles correctly</p>                                                           | In-memory role repository works correctly for testing        |
| **InMemoryPermissionRepository**  | Should provide in-memory permission storage for testing  | <p>- Permission creation works correctly<br>- Permission retrieval by ID works<br>- Permission listing works<br>- Permission updating works<br>- Permission deletion works<br>- Permission format validation works<br>- Handles multiple permissions correctly</p>               | In-memory permission repository works correctly for testing  |

### 13. Test Execution Strategy

#### 13.1 Test Execution Order

| Test Type             | Execution Order | Description                                                | Expected Duration |
| --------------------- | --------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------- |
| **Unit Tests**        | 1st Priority    | Fast execution, high isolation, test individual components | 2-5 minutes       |
| **Integration Tests** | 2nd Priority    | Medium execution time, test component interactions         | 5-15 minutes      |
| **End-to-End Tests**  | 3rd Priority    | Slow execution, test complete user workflows               | 15-30 minutes     |
| **Performance Tests** | 4th Priority    | Separate execution, resource intensive testing             | 30-60 minutes     |
| **Security Tests**    | 5th Priority    | Separate execution, specialized security tools             | 10-20 minutes     |

#### 13.2 Test Environment Setup

| Environment                 | Purpose                            | Configuration                                                                                                     | Test Coverage                     |
| --------------------------- | ---------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------------- |
| **Development Environment** | Local development and unit testing | <p>- Local database<br>- In-memory repositories<br>- Mock external services<br>- Fast execution</p>               | Unit tests, integration tests     |
| **Staging Environment**     | Integration and E2E testing        | <p>- Staging database<br>- Real external services<br>- Production-like configuration<br>- Full system testing</p> | Integration tests, E2E tests      |
| **Production Environment**  | Performance and security testing   | <p>- Production database<br>- Real external services<br>- Production configuration<br>- Load testing</p>          | Performance tests, security tests |

### 14. Test Reporting

#### 14.1 Test Metrics

| Metric                        | Description                            | Target                                           | Measurement Method                 |
| ----------------------------- | -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ | ---------------------------------- |
| **Test Coverage Percentage**  | Percentage of code covered by tests    | ≥ 80%                                            | Code coverage tools (Vitest, Jest) |
| **Pass/Fail Ratios**          | Ratio of passing vs failing tests      | ≥ 95% pass rate                                  | Test execution reports             |
| **Execution Time Metrics**    | Time taken to execute test suites      | Unit: < 5min, Integration: < 15min, E2E: < 30min | Test execution timing              |
| **Bug Severity Distribution** | Distribution of bugs by severity level | Blocker: 0%, Severe: < 5%, Moderate: < 15%       | Bug tracking system                |
| **Test Reliability**          | Consistency of test results            | ≥ 98% reliability                                | Test flakiness analysis            |
| **Performance Benchmarks**    | Response time and throughput metrics   | Meets performance requirements                   | Performance monitoring tools       |

#### 14.2 Test Reports

| Report Type                      | Frequency | Content                                                                                                                                     | Audience                              |
| -------------------------------- | --------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- |
| **Daily Test Execution Reports** | Daily     | <p>- Test execution results<br>- Pass/fail statistics<br>- Failed test details<br>- Performance metrics<br>- Coverage updates</p>           | Development team, QA team             |
| **Weekly Test Coverage Reports** | Weekly    | <p>- Coverage trends<br>- Coverage gaps<br>- New test additions<br>- Coverage improvements<br>- Coverage targets</p>                        | Development team, QA team, Management |
| **Monthly Test Quality Metrics** | Monthly   | <p>- Test quality trends<br>- Bug detection rates<br>- Test effectiveness<br>- Quality improvements<br>- Process improvements</p>           | QA team, Management                   |
| **Bug Trend Analysis**           | Monthly   | <p>- Bug severity trends<br>- Bug frequency analysis<br>- Bug resolution times<br>- Bug prevention strategies<br>- Quality improvements</p> | Development team, QA team, Management |

### 15. Continuous Integration

#### 15.1 CI/CD Pipeline

| Pipeline Stage                 | Description                      | Tools                       | Success Criteria                                                                                                 |
| ------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | --------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Code Quality Check**         | Static code analysis and linting | ESLint, Prettier, SonarQube | <p>- No critical code smells<br>- Code style compliance<br>- Security vulnerabilities detected</p>               |
| **Unit Test Execution**        | Run all unit tests automatically | Vitest, Jest                | <p>- All unit tests pass<br>- Coverage ≥ 80%<br>- Execution time < 5 minutes</p>                                 |
| **Integration Test Execution** | Run integration tests            | Vitest, Supertest           | <p>- All integration tests pass<br>- Database integration works<br>- API endpoints work correctly</p>            |
| **E2E Test Execution**         | Run end-to-end tests             | Cypress, Selenium           | <p>- All E2E tests pass<br>- User workflows work correctly<br>- Cross-browser compatibility</p>                  |
| **Performance Test Execution** | Run performance tests            | Artillery, JMeter           | <p>- Performance benchmarks met<br>- Response times acceptable<br>- Load handling works</p>                      |
| **Security Test Execution**    | Run security tests               | OWASP ZAP, npm audit        | <p>- No critical security vulnerabilities<br>- Security scan passes<br>- Dependency vulnerabilities resolved</p> |
| **Deployment**                 | Deploy to staging/production     | Docker, Kubernetes          | <p>- Application deploys successfully<br>- Health checks pass<br>- Monitoring works correctly</p>                |

#### 15.2 Quality Gates

| Quality Gate      | Criteria                             | Enforcement | Action on Failure                                                                   |
| ----------------- | ------------------------------------ | ----------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **Test Coverage** | ≥ 80% code coverage                  | Automated   | <p>- Block deployment<br>- Generate report<br>- Notify development team</p>         |
| **Test Results**  | All tests must pass                  | Automated   | <p>- Block deployment<br>- Generate failure report<br>- Notify development team</p> |
| **Bug Severity**  | No Blocker/Critical bugs             | Automated   | <p>- Block deployment<br>- Generate bug report<br>- Notify QA team</p>              |
| **Performance**   | Meet performance benchmarks          | Automated   | <p>- Block deployment<br>- Generate performance report<br>- Notify DevOps team</p>  |
| **Security**      | No critical security vulnerabilities | Automated   | <p>- Block deployment<br>- Generate security report<br>- Notify security team</p>   |
| **Code Quality**  | Pass code quality checks             | Automated   | <p>- Block deployment<br>- Generate quality report<br>- Notify development team</p> |

***

**Version**: 1.0.0\
**Last Update**: July 2025\
**Author**: Antonio Silva\
**Email**: <contato@antoniobsilva.com.br>
